A non-government entityMyMedicarePlans
Data for reporters and researchers

One insurer enrolls a majority of Medicare Advantage members in 9 of 62 counties in New York

By · Published · Last updated · Data: CMS Medicare Advantage enrollment by county, 2026 · Free to use with credit (CC BY 4.0)

On this page: The finding Chart Table Cite Methodology More for New York Contact

In 9 of the 62 counties in New York with Medicare Advantage enrollment reported, one insurer enrolls a majority of the county's Medicare Advantage members, according to CMS Medicare Advantage enrollment data for 2026.

Lifetime Healthcare Inc has the most members in 27 of them. The table gives the largest insurer and its share in every county counted.

The chart

The largest insurer's share of Medicare Advantage members, by county in New YorkIn Ontario County, Lifetime Healthcare Inc enrolls 71%.Ontario County71% Lifetime Healthcare IncWayne County68% Lifetime Healthcare IncYates County64% Lifetime Healthcare IncLivingston County58% Lifetime Healthcare IncMonroe County58% Lifetime Healthcare IncSeneca County53% Lifetime Healthcare IncTompkins County53% Aetna (CVS Health)Orleans County52% UnitedHealthcareBronx County51% Healthfirst IncFranklin County49% Aetna (CVS Health)Albany County45% Lifetime Healthcare IncNew York County43% Healthfirst IncRensselaer County43% Lifetime Healthcare IncJefferson County42% UnitedHealthcareSuffolk County42% Aetna (CVS Health)
The largest insurer's share of Medicare Advantage members, by county in New York. Source: CMS Medicare Advantage enrollment by county, 2026.

The table behind it

The largest Medicare Advantage insurer in each county of New York, 2026
CountyLargest insurerIts shareMembers listed
Ontario CountyLifetime Healthcare Inc71%21,662
Wayne CountyLifetime Healthcare Inc68%17,589
Yates CountyLifetime Healthcare Inc64%4,310
Livingston CountyLifetime Healthcare Inc58%11,400
Monroe CountyLifetime Healthcare Inc58%133,200
Seneca CountyLifetime Healthcare Inc53%5,128
Tompkins CountyAetna (CVS Health)53%8,516
Orleans CountyUnitedHealthcare52%6,847
Bronx CountyHealthfirst Inc51%146,854
Franklin CountyAetna (CVS Health)49%5,472
Albany CountyLifetime Healthcare Inc45%33,356
New York CountyHealthfirst Inc43%125,402
Rensselaer CountyLifetime Healthcare Inc43%18,045
Jefferson CountyUnitedHealthcare42%11,540
Suffolk CountyAetna (CVS Health)42%92,634
Dutchess CountyUnitedHealthcare41%27,988
Saratoga CountyLifetime Healthcare Inc41%31,485
Cortland CountyLifetime Healthcare Inc40%5,422
Oswego CountyUnitedHealthcare40%17,930
Herkimer CountyLifetime Healthcare Inc39%8,936
Genesee CountyUnitedHealthcare38%9,728
Otsego CountyHumana38%6,886
Schoharie CountyLifetime Healthcare Inc38%3,930
Clinton CountyAetna (CVS Health)37%8,390
Oneida CountyLifetime Healthcare Inc37%30,722
Allegany CountyUnitedHealthcare36%6,409
Kings CountyHealthfirst Inc36%204,241
Putnam CountyUnitedHealthcare36%8,083
Queens CountyHealthfirst Inc36%222,896
Essex CountyAetna (CVS Health)35%4,128
Lewis CountyLifetime Healthcare Inc35%3,883
Hamilton CountyAetna (CVS Health)34%802
Richmond CountyAetna (CVS Health)34%42,414
Rockland CountyAetna (CVS Health)34%18,429
Schenectady CountyLifetime Healthcare Inc34%20,341
Schuyler CountyLifetime Healthcare Inc34%2,929
Tioga CountyLifetime Healthcare Inc34%8,298
Cayuga CountyLifetime Healthcare Inc33%10,708
Chemung CountyUnitedHealthcare33%12,979
Columbia CountyLifetime Healthcare Inc33%7,035
Greene CountyLifetime Healthcare Inc33%6,138
Westchester CountyAetna (CVS Health)33%71,094
Madison CountyLifetime Healthcare Inc32%9,750
Nassau CountyAetna (CVS Health)32%91,254
Steuben CountyUnitedHealthcare32%15,003
Washington CountyUnitedHealthcare32%9,367
Montgomery CountyLifetime Healthcare Inc31%7,330
Orange CountyAetna (CVS Health)31%25,556
Warren CountyLifetime Healthcare Inc31%10,907
Wyoming CountyLifetime Healthcare Inc31%6,294
Broome CountyLifetime Healthcare Inc30%29,388
Chenango CountyLifetime Healthcare Inc30%8,231
Delaware CountyAetna (CVS Health)30%5,695
Niagara CountyUnitedHealthcare30%38,819
Onondaga CountyUnitedHealthcare30%64,141
Ulster CountyUnitedHealthcare30%18,834
Sullivan CountyAetna (CVS Health)29%6,754
Cattaraugus CountyUnitedHealthcare26%12,056
Fulton CountyLifetime Healthcare Inc25%8,415
St. Lawrence CountyAetna (CVS Health)25%12,263
Chautauqua CountyUnitedHealthcare24%20,763
Erie CountyIndependent Health Association Inc23%150,409

The same rows as a CSV file at a stable address, with a header row.

Download the table (CSV)

Cite this

Credit line: Source: MyMedicarePlans.org analysis of CMS Medicare Advantage enrollment by county, 2026 (https://mymedicareplans.org/newsroom/findings/counties-where-one-insurer-has-a-medicare-advantage-majority/new-york/)

Reference: MyMedicarePlans.org Data Desk (2026). One Insurer Enrolls a Majority of Medicare Advantage Members in 9 of 62 New York Counties. MyMedicarePlans.org. https://mymedicareplans.org/newsroom/findings/counties-where-one-insurer-has-a-medicare-advantage-majority/new-york/

Free to use under Creative Commons Attribution 4.0: credit MyMedicarePlans.org with a link to this page. Terms and how to cite.

Methodology

Source
CMS Monthly MA Enrollment by State/County/Contract, grouped by parent organization (CMS SCC MA Enrollment (Alt) + CY Landscape Source File (parent-org map).). The insurers desk's method.
Date retrieved
File built 2026-06-01.
Sample
The 62 counties in New York with Medicare Advantage enrollment reported.
How it was calculated
In each county with enrollment reported, enrollment is summed by parent organization; the county is counted when the largest organization's rounded share is above 50%.
Known limits
  • The county file keeps each county's six largest insurers and rounds shares to a whole percent; a majority is a rounded share above 50%.
  • Counties with no enrollment reported are not counted. CMS withholds any contract-county count of 10 or fewer, so the smallest counties rest on few members.
  • Enrollment includes employer group members, who are in the same contracts.
  • Enrollment is for 2026; it does not yet reflect plans ending for the next plan year.

The full data: New York on the insurers desk. Every dataset: the data library.

More numbers for New York

Questions about the data

Write to [email protected]: a custom cut of the data (a county list, a region, a chart in your outlet's size) is usually a same-day reply.

For a quote or an interview, write to the same address and the desk that covers it answers: the Data Desk for the plan counts and the county data, the Costs & Policy Desk for Part D, premiums, IRMAA and Extra Help, the Editorial Desk for how Medicare works, Medigap and enrollment. Every answer comes from the CMS files and Medicare's own rules.

MyMedicarePlans.org is a Medicare guide: plain-language answers and plan data for people choosing coverage. The counts here come only from the CMS files, and the method is above. Not connected with or endorsed by the U.S. government or the federal Medicare program.