One insurer enrolls a majority of Medicare Advantage members in 9 of 62 counties in New York
By MyMedicarePlans Data Desk · Published · Last updated · Data: CMS Medicare Advantage enrollment by county, 2026 · Free to use with credit (CC BY 4.0)
On this page: The finding Chart Table Cite Methodology More for New York Contact
In 9 of the 62 counties in New York with Medicare Advantage enrollment reported, one insurer enrolls a majority of the county's Medicare Advantage members, according to CMS Medicare Advantage enrollment data for 2026.
Lifetime Healthcare Inc has the most members in 27 of them. The table gives the largest insurer and its share in every county counted.
The chart
The table behind it
| County | Largest insurer | Its share | Members listed |
|---|---|---|---|
| Ontario County | Lifetime Healthcare Inc | 71% | 21,662 |
| Wayne County | Lifetime Healthcare Inc | 68% | 17,589 |
| Yates County | Lifetime Healthcare Inc | 64% | 4,310 |
| Livingston County | Lifetime Healthcare Inc | 58% | 11,400 |
| Monroe County | Lifetime Healthcare Inc | 58% | 133,200 |
| Seneca County | Lifetime Healthcare Inc | 53% | 5,128 |
| Tompkins County | Aetna (CVS Health) | 53% | 8,516 |
| Orleans County | UnitedHealthcare | 52% | 6,847 |
| Bronx County | Healthfirst Inc | 51% | 146,854 |
| Franklin County | Aetna (CVS Health) | 49% | 5,472 |
| Albany County | Lifetime Healthcare Inc | 45% | 33,356 |
| New York County | Healthfirst Inc | 43% | 125,402 |
| Rensselaer County | Lifetime Healthcare Inc | 43% | 18,045 |
| Jefferson County | UnitedHealthcare | 42% | 11,540 |
| Suffolk County | Aetna (CVS Health) | 42% | 92,634 |
| Dutchess County | UnitedHealthcare | 41% | 27,988 |
| Saratoga County | Lifetime Healthcare Inc | 41% | 31,485 |
| Cortland County | Lifetime Healthcare Inc | 40% | 5,422 |
| Oswego County | UnitedHealthcare | 40% | 17,930 |
| Herkimer County | Lifetime Healthcare Inc | 39% | 8,936 |
| Genesee County | UnitedHealthcare | 38% | 9,728 |
| Otsego County | Humana | 38% | 6,886 |
| Schoharie County | Lifetime Healthcare Inc | 38% | 3,930 |
| Clinton County | Aetna (CVS Health) | 37% | 8,390 |
| Oneida County | Lifetime Healthcare Inc | 37% | 30,722 |
| Allegany County | UnitedHealthcare | 36% | 6,409 |
| Kings County | Healthfirst Inc | 36% | 204,241 |
| Putnam County | UnitedHealthcare | 36% | 8,083 |
| Queens County | Healthfirst Inc | 36% | 222,896 |
| Essex County | Aetna (CVS Health) | 35% | 4,128 |
| Lewis County | Lifetime Healthcare Inc | 35% | 3,883 |
| Hamilton County | Aetna (CVS Health) | 34% | 802 |
| Richmond County | Aetna (CVS Health) | 34% | 42,414 |
| Rockland County | Aetna (CVS Health) | 34% | 18,429 |
| Schenectady County | Lifetime Healthcare Inc | 34% | 20,341 |
| Schuyler County | Lifetime Healthcare Inc | 34% | 2,929 |
| Tioga County | Lifetime Healthcare Inc | 34% | 8,298 |
| Cayuga County | Lifetime Healthcare Inc | 33% | 10,708 |
| Chemung County | UnitedHealthcare | 33% | 12,979 |
| Columbia County | Lifetime Healthcare Inc | 33% | 7,035 |
| Greene County | Lifetime Healthcare Inc | 33% | 6,138 |
| Westchester County | Aetna (CVS Health) | 33% | 71,094 |
| Madison County | Lifetime Healthcare Inc | 32% | 9,750 |
| Nassau County | Aetna (CVS Health) | 32% | 91,254 |
| Steuben County | UnitedHealthcare | 32% | 15,003 |
| Washington County | UnitedHealthcare | 32% | 9,367 |
| Montgomery County | Lifetime Healthcare Inc | 31% | 7,330 |
| Orange County | Aetna (CVS Health) | 31% | 25,556 |
| Warren County | Lifetime Healthcare Inc | 31% | 10,907 |
| Wyoming County | Lifetime Healthcare Inc | 31% | 6,294 |
| Broome County | Lifetime Healthcare Inc | 30% | 29,388 |
| Chenango County | Lifetime Healthcare Inc | 30% | 8,231 |
| Delaware County | Aetna (CVS Health) | 30% | 5,695 |
| Niagara County | UnitedHealthcare | 30% | 38,819 |
| Onondaga County | UnitedHealthcare | 30% | 64,141 |
| Ulster County | UnitedHealthcare | 30% | 18,834 |
| Sullivan County | Aetna (CVS Health) | 29% | 6,754 |
| Cattaraugus County | UnitedHealthcare | 26% | 12,056 |
| Fulton County | Lifetime Healthcare Inc | 25% | 8,415 |
| St. Lawrence County | Aetna (CVS Health) | 25% | 12,263 |
| Chautauqua County | UnitedHealthcare | 24% | 20,763 |
| Erie County | Independent Health Association Inc | 23% | 150,409 |
The same rows as a CSV file at a stable address, with a header row.
Cite this
Credit line: Source: MyMedicarePlans.org analysis of CMS Medicare Advantage enrollment by county, 2026 (https://mymedicareplans.org/newsroom/findings/counties-where-one-insurer-has-a-medicare-advantage-majority/new-york/)
Reference: MyMedicarePlans.org Data Desk (2026). One Insurer Enrolls a Majority of Medicare Advantage Members in 9 of 62 New York Counties. MyMedicarePlans.org. https://mymedicareplans.org/newsroom/findings/counties-where-one-insurer-has-a-medicare-advantage-majority/new-york/
Free to use under Creative Commons Attribution 4.0: credit MyMedicarePlans.org with a link to this page. Terms and how to cite.
Methodology
- Source
- CMS Monthly MA Enrollment by State/County/Contract, grouped by parent organization (CMS SCC MA Enrollment (Alt) + CY Landscape Source File (parent-org map).). The insurers desk's method.
- Date retrieved
- File built 2026-06-01.
- Sample
- The 62 counties in New York with Medicare Advantage enrollment reported.
- How it was calculated
- In each county with enrollment reported, enrollment is summed by parent organization; the county is counted when the largest organization's rounded share is above 50%.
- Known limits
- The county file keeps each county's six largest insurers and rounds shares to a whole percent; a majority is a rounded share above 50%.
- Counties with no enrollment reported are not counted. CMS withholds any contract-county count of 10 or fewer, so the smallest counties rest on few members.
- Enrollment includes employer group members, who are in the same contracts.
- Enrollment is for 2026; it does not yet reflect plans ending for the next plan year.
The full data: New York on the insurers desk. Every dataset: the data library.
More numbers for New York
- The national finding: One insurer enrolls a majority of Medicare Advantage members in 1,194 of 3,053 U.S. counties
- 63 of the 218 Medicare Advantage plans offered in New York are not returning in 2027
- 224 Medicare Advantage plans are offered in New York for 2027, against 218 in 2026
- 2 organizations that offered Medicare Advantage plans in New York in 2026 offer none there for 2027; 1 is new
- 62 of 62 counties in New York lose at least one Medicare Advantage plan in 2027
- 58 of 62 counties in New York have fewer Medicare Advantage plans in 2027 than in 2026; 4 have more
- 33.1% of general-enrollment Medicare Advantage plans with drug coverage in New York, 42 of 127, charge a $0 monthly premium in 2027
- 41 of 87 general-enrollment Medicare Advantage plans with drug coverage in New York raise their monthly premium for 2027; 15 lower it and 31 keep it the same
- UnitedHealthcare enrolls 18.5% of Medicare Advantage members in New York, as of May 2026
- 97 of 193 rated Medicare Advantage plans in New York (50.3%) have 4 stars or more in CMS's 2027 Star Ratings
- 7 of 193 rated Medicare Advantage plans in New York have 5 stars in CMS's 2027 Star Ratings
- 46.4% of Medicare Advantage enrollees in New York are in contracts CMS rates 4 stars or higher for 2027
- 20 chronic condition Special Needs Plans (C-SNPs) are offered in New York for 2027, up from 5 in 2026
- 50 dual-eligible Special Needs Plans (D-SNPs) are offered in New York for 2027, down from 57 in 2026
- 9 stand-alone Medicare Part D drug plans are offered in New York for 2027, down from 10 in 2026
- 0 stand-alone Part D plans with a $0 monthly premium are offered in New York for 2027, the same as the 0 in 2026
- The lowest stand-alone Medicare Part D premium in New York in 2027 is $37.30 a month, against $35.70 in 2026
- 0 stand-alone Part D plans with a $0 deductible are offered in New York for 2027, down from 1 in 2026
- 2 stand-alone Part D plans that cost $0 a month with full Extra Help are offered in New York for 2027, the same as the 2 in 2026
- 72% of Medicare Advantage enrollees in New York, about 1,259,800 people, could be turned down for a Medigap policy, KFF estimates
- At least 8 insurers sell Medigap policies in New York, on Medicare.gov's search for one ZIP code
- 4,431 people and companies with an address in New York are on the HHS inspector general's exclusion list
- Medicare Advantage Share Index: New York
- New York: the newsroom's brief, with every county
Questions about the data
Write to [email protected]: a custom cut of the data (a county list, a region, a chart in your outlet's size) is usually a same-day reply.
For a quote or an interview, write to the same address and the desk that covers it answers: the Data Desk for the plan counts and the county data, the Costs & Policy Desk for Part D, premiums, IRMAA and Extra Help, the Editorial Desk for how Medicare works, Medigap and enrollment. Every answer comes from the CMS files and Medicare's own rules.
MyMedicarePlans.org is a Medicare guide: plain-language answers and plan data for people choosing coverage. The counts here come only from the CMS files, and the method is above. Not connected with or endorsed by the U.S. government or the federal Medicare program.